|
During the conference, it became apparent that successful
multi-state collaboration has three overarching elements—addresses
complex problems; provides efficiency and effective program structure;
and capitalizes on shared excellence.
Complex problems demand complex solutions not readily
investigated by individual scientists or institutions. Examples
of such critical agricultural issues are global warming (see related
sidebar), animal well being, water quality and distribution, and
nutrient flow.
Multi-state
collaborations yield efficiency and effectiveness when limited expertise
or resources are used to benefit diverse clientele and stakeholders
who have similar needs or problems. Georgia, South Carolina and
North Carolina jointly employ a specialist in orchard floor weed
management, a critical need for fruit growers in that region (see
related sidebar).
Shared excellence allows Land Grant universities to
provide richer experiences and benefits to farmers, students, businesses
and other clients. For example, a cooperative academic program allows
students from 13 Midwest schools to study poultry science (see related
sidebar). A university’s participation in a foreign agricultural
endeavor can yield knowledge that is applicable to problems in its
home state. A distance learning program could bring together the
best minds in biochemistry for a graduate seminar.
Conference participants discussed other elements critical
to successful multi-state collaborative projects. They fall into
four major categories: mutual benefits, structure, teamwork and
program assessment.
Mutual benefits: Collaborative projects need to
be win-win situations for all the players. The gains and costs to
each player may not be equal, but each player needs to gain from
the venture. Hand-in-hand with that is mutual respect for the role
of each player at the table. Project expectations must also be shared—by
the participating universities, students or industry stakeholders.
Structure: Collaborative projects are ideal structures
for integrated research, education and outreach programs. Interdisciplinary/multidisciplinary
approaches to sound science are needed to address today’s complex
issues, issues that are ideal for collaborative ventures. Upper
level and graduate coursework—specifically those areas with specialized
needs and low enrollment—offer obvious opportunities for collaborative
academic programs. Collaborative programs also provide an opportunity
to use innovative delivery models, such as distance education, student/faculty
exchanges, internships or cooperative education.
Teamwork: Across the board, collegiality is required—among
academicians, students and stakeholders. Successful collaborative
programs require the full involvement and support of all faculty
members.
Key to any multi-state collaboration project is a
champion—the person or persons who maintain momentum for a project
by cultivating support from within and outside the university.
Consistent policies are needed across the Land Grant
university system to recognize and reward faculty work in collaborative
programs, as well as to recognize such projects and faculty roles
in the budget process. While maximizing resource efficiency, collaborative
programs still require appropriate staff, infrastructure support
and funding to be successful. Memoranda of understanding (MOU) between
participating institutions can be used to address registration,
credit and grade transfers, as well as budget details, liability
and accountability issues.
Project assessment: Periodic review
is needed of each program’s objectives and results. This should
include review of the program’s purpose; review of personnel needs
and performance; and a strong outcome-based evaluation.
|